The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty The Husaynis 17001948 Ilan Pappe 9780863564536 Books
Download As PDF : The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty The Husaynis 17001948 Ilan Pappe 9780863564536 Books
Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty
The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty The Husaynis 17001948 Ilan Pappe 9780863564536 Books
This book had the potential to be truly groundbreaking, since its subject (the Husayni family) has never received the rich historical treatment it deserved. However, the work is extremely flawed in many respects. There are a myriad of problems: the colloquial narrative (“As we shall see”); clunky language; numerous unsubstantiated statements and claims; lack of citations; insertions of Pappe’s anti-Israeli opinions on 21st century events; and far too much foreshadowing of the post-World War II 20th century. Many people will find Pappe’s anti-Zionist bias tough to stomach. Pappe’s refusal to make distinctions about the other side (“the Jews” or “the Zionists”) is in marked contrast to his fine variegating between the different Palestinian Arab (and even British) societal elements. Similarly, he provides maddening sartorial detail about several Husaynis, but refuses to discuss their roles in or opinions on some of the major events of the day in mandatory Palestine. The lacunae and elisions are stunning. Nonetheless, the complicated Husayni family history is fascinating and Pappe does a great job detailing it, not to mention chronicling internal familial dynamics as well as battling amongst the Palestinian notables. He makes great strides in eradicating the demonic caricature of al-Hajj Amin Husayni and humanizing him. But overall, as far as academic books go, it is very poorly written and edited – I wonder how Berkeley let it through in this state of factual mistakes, typos, and non-chronological rambling. If his writing was an attempt to emulate his subjects’ seemingly limited and pained ahistorical grasp of the intricacies of the Zionist movement(s) and the modern world, well then, he has succeeded. Such stylistic motifs are best left to literature though, and not historical research.Product details
|
Tags : The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty: The Husaynis, 1700-1948 [Ilan Pappe] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty,Ilan Pappe,The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty: The Husaynis, 1700-1948,Saqi Books,0863564534,Biographies & Memoirs - Biographies
People also read other books :
- Milkshakes and Murder A Comedy Cozy Mom and Christy Cozy Mysteries Book 3 edition by Christy Murphy Mystery Thriller Suspense eBooks
- Der Auftrag German Edition Urs Rauscher Books
- Gary Patterson Cats Wall Calendar Mead 9781682090701 Books
- Finding Yourself Discover How to Find Yourself Define Yourself and Pave Your Own Path Into the Future edition by Ian Branneth SelfHelp eBooks
- Pray for This Boy Eric Crawford 9781490540764 Books
The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty The Husaynis 17001948 Ilan Pappe 9780863564536 Books Reviews
pappe writes about a small dependant part (Palestine) of the large Ottoman Empire, without having consulted any Ottoman archives or Turkish sources (0 references). Moreover, according to his endnotes, he only spent little time in the local archives (Haram) ignoring thus substantial sources.
In fact, many of his references seem to be little reliable, directing to other scholars or Arab politicians memoirs (rather than to neutral or primary sources), making light or wrong 'conclusions' despite all other strikingly clear evidence (which he conveniently ignores). Not inclusive enough and somewhat distorting, to say the least..
Prof. Pappe is a courageous scholar and he showcases his erudition once again in "The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty." He does more than marshal facts, he presents the heart and soul of a nation so besieged they are the objects of the denial of their very existence. 2012 Republican Presidential contender Newt Gingrich claims the Palestinians didn't happen. When people say the "Holocaust" didn't happen they lose all credibility in polite society and the establishment media, but Mr. Gingrich and his billionaire backer, casino magnate Shelson Adelson can spout this hateful gibberish and still maintain their gravtias and reputation on Fox News.
Pappe does not condescend to stoop to the appalling fantasies of presidential contenders and Zionist fanatics. Rather he sets about laying the foundation of a heartbreaking story of a family whose fortunes were tied to their ancestral land and declined with it, while few in America who enabled that degradation, mourned.
Everything Pappe writes is of great interest; this work particularly so -- a dose of reality injected into an American political scene which has become so hallucinatory it actually entertains the non-existence of a whole people. How much crazier can it get?
One supposes America can surpass its insanity if it bombs Iran to stop its "weapons of mass destruction." Every decade an American war for Israeli objectives based on a chimera?
I've read the older Hebrew edition. This is a great epic historical account of the family, from its formation as the "Husayni" family to its collapse as a nobility together with rest of Arab Palestine. The family's story is skillfully intertwined with that of the larger events taking place in the region and the world as a whole. On the down side, references are rather scant(mostly one or two per page, with only one or two sources mentioned, sometimes again and again for a certain amount of pages). Also, the author's notorious bias in favor of the Palestinian narrative of the conflict is clearly evident, mostly in his apologetic treatment of Amin al-Husayni. Still, this book sheds light on a new angle of Palestinian history that has yet to be rivaled as such.
Pappe has finally translated one of his first works. The history of the Husayinis is one that should be read by any scholar working on Palestine but it is also a pleasant reading for the occasional reader. Pity that the publisher didn't spot a large amount of typos and other silly mistakes.
Israel Shamir dares see the human side of the Palestinian people and what he sees is mostly heartwarming. If all Israelis were made to see the same thing it would sap the basis of the state of Israel as a land for the "Chosen People". He is certainly accused of ignoring all the criminal acts committed by the Palestinians mostly to defend the land thay still have and which is being taken from them by the square meter; he seems to carry the weight of this criticism graciously.
Shamir puts the question indirectly and that question is what do you do with five million people under your control when you cannot dare give them all the rights of citizenship, for those within Israel, and the rights of a nation for those outside. Letting all the people in the land of Palestine live together with the same rights and obligations. A dream? Not quite, but this wil require some cataclysmic changes in the world for this to happen. Look at all the cataclysms of the 20th. century and you will understand that cataclysms do not occur so seldom.
This book had the potential to be truly groundbreaking, since its subject (the Husayni family) has never received the rich historical treatment it deserved. However, the work is extremely flawed in many respects. There are a myriad of problems the colloquial narrative (“As we shall see”); clunky language; numerous unsubstantiated statements and claims; lack of citations; insertions of Pappe’s anti-Israeli opinions on 21st century events; and far too much foreshadowing of the post-World War II 20th century. Many people will find Pappe’s anti-Zionist bias tough to stomach. Pappe’s refusal to make distinctions about the other side (“the Jews” or “the Zionists”) is in marked contrast to his fine variegating between the different Palestinian Arab (and even British) societal elements. Similarly, he provides maddening sartorial detail about several Husaynis, but refuses to discuss their roles in or opinions on some of the major events of the day in mandatory Palestine. The lacunae and elisions are stunning. Nonetheless, the complicated Husayni family history is fascinating and Pappe does a great job detailing it, not to mention chronicling internal familial dynamics as well as battling amongst the Palestinian notables. He makes great strides in eradicating the demonic caricature of al-Hajj Amin Husayni and humanizing him. But overall, as far as academic books go, it is very poorly written and edited – I wonder how Berkeley let it through in this state of factual mistakes, typos, and non-chronological rambling. If his writing was an attempt to emulate his subjects’ seemingly limited and pained ahistorical grasp of the intricacies of the Zionist movement(s) and the modern world, well then, he has succeeded. Such stylistic motifs are best left to literature though, and not historical research.
0 Response to "∎ [PDF] The Rise and Fall of a Palestinian Dynasty The Husaynis 17001948 Ilan Pappe 9780863564536 Books"
Post a Comment